I understand about liquidy, is just a proposal. Effectively I have no seen the liquidity fragmentation. BNC and V Token standart permit you to be liquid more two assets distincs with their own liquidity. Effectivly, this choice would be better in HDX. But before vMANTA/MANTA, vPHA/PHA. And for the rest is HDX. I understand the think. All is clear for me, with it's possible without fragmentation or with liquidity on Omnipool HDX only.
However, create an additivity of dual token on one pool like on Balancer is good idea for the futur I think.
Thanks for your answer!
Edited
Hi @g28y...ehnV
vPHA is still in our To Do list and planned for Q2 at the moment.
I think we won't open any direct pool like this on Bifrost side. It has non sense.
We open stablepool for swaps like vMANTA/MANTA or vPHA/PHA or vDOT/DOT or vGLMR/GLMR.
If you want to have routing between pools in our DEX or swap options, you need to have a common pool with BNC for instance.
BNC/vPHA + BNC/vMANTA
or
DOT/PHA + DOT/MANTA + stablepools vPHA/PHA and vMANTA/MANTA
-> It will just split the liquidity
Or, an even better solution would be to have vPHA in the HydraDX omnipool along side with vMANTA.
But this requires to build liquidity for both 1st.